Sherlock Holmes. This particular
story made me very delighted as there is finally a competent adversary to face
off against Sherlock, the woman. She consistently outwits him and stays one
step ahead of all of Sherlock’s plans. This was very much seen in the extra
credit video that we saw Tuesday night from the television/mini-series Sherlock. In the video we saw that “the
woman” managed to poison Sherlock, faked her death, and managed to throw him
through a loop when it came to trying to figure out the pass-code to her cell
phone. This is such an uncommon situation when it comes to Sherlock because he
is known for being one of the greatest – if not the greatest – deductive specialists.
He never misses anything, not even the minutest detail. So this makes it very
interesting that this random woman is able to “pull the wool” over Sherlock’s
eyes. The shows makes it clear that Sherlock and “the woman” have feelings for
one another, whether those feelings are love or just admiration for a fellow
genius is still to be seen. Nonetheless, it is quite clear to me that whatever
the feelings he had for the woman made him vulnerable to her tactics – just as
her feelings for him allowed him to beat her in the end. It truly is a riveting
story line.
Another really intriguing story we
read was Rudyard Kipling’s The Man Who
Would Be King. The story of Daniel Dravot and Peachey Carnehan going into
the foreign land of Kafiristan to make themselves kings is a dream that most
people have – I am referring to the being a king/queen, not taking over another
land. They accomplished this by making the Kafiristan locals believe that the
two of them were Gods among men. However, Daniel gets greedy and tries to take
a wife which was against the rules. The woman was frightened and ended up
biting Daniel causing him to bleed which showed the locals that the two of them
were in fact not Gods, but mere humans like themselves. The locals turned
against Daniel and Peachey, killed Daniel by making him fall to his death, and
staked Peachey with wooden stakes – that is quite the grotesque scene when
seeing the movie version. In the end, all Peachey has to remember his time as a
king is the decapitated head of his dear friend (Daniel) and the crown that was
upon his head when he fell to his death. Now if that isn’t a story that you can
really sink your teeth into, than I don’t know what is!
These two stories both kept the
three of us on the edge of our seats because they both included many plot
twists. The fact that they were able to capture our attention so vehemently really
shows how intriguing the two authors wrote their stories! This being said, we
believe that the best stories frequently have thrilling endings that nobody
sees coming (or at least, that is the idea the authors have in mind).
I really enjoyed reading your post! I, too, loved this episode of Sherlock Holmes because he is so taken aback by this woman that in many cases is hilarious. He thinks so highly of himself--mainly because he can't be beaten--and for Irene Adler to step in and steal the show from him is pure entertainment! I found it interesting that in the show it makes it clear that Sherlock and "the woman" share a romantic chemistry between them. One scene I remember is her trying to seduce him (and it almost works!). However, in the story, I did not pick up on that aspect at all. In the story I just got the sense that he was frustrated and when he found out she was a woman he was shocked.
ReplyDelete"The Man Who Would Be King" was a good story too, definitely not my favorite though. This story touched on some really great points. For example, it represents the British/European cultures who just feel like they can take over for no apparent reason. The comedy clip that was played (I forget the name of the comedian) described it perfectly with the "if you don't have a flag then we are taking over" ideals.
Overall, I really enjoyed this weeks reading!
--British Lit for the Win (Emily, Hayley, Sydney)
This was a very good post. I really enjoyed how you guys used the word delightful. It was a perfect word because it was indeed an awesome plot twist to see Sherlock Holmes have the most trouble with a woman. This is unlike many other detective stories, especially with someone of Mr. Holmes intelligence. I also really liked how you brought up the whole cell-phone aspect of the movie. This was a small item, yet made the whole plot climax the way it did. You guys brought up many good points and its very evident that you know what you are talking about and paid attention for this unit. This was a very good post and overall deserves a thumbs. This response was brought to you by TEAM WHY. Savanah and Joshua.
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed the post, too, and would agree with your commenters. Here's the Eddie Izzard clip: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uEx5G-GOS1k
ReplyDelete