I really loved the story “The Luck of Roaring Camp” by Bret
Harte. I’ve always been a fan of Western
literature. Growing up my favorite movie
was Tombstone. I loved all of the wild
action, the lack of law and order, the abundance of gunfights. I could watch Tombstone every day of the week
without it ever getting old. When I was
reading “The Luck of Roaring Camp” I noticed all of the similarities between
how that town, Roaring Camp, and the town of Tombstone are represented. Roaring Camp is dirty, rugged, full of criminals
all running from the law, very much like Tombstone. Tombstone is run by a gang, the law in that
town is virtually nonexistent due to the fear that the gang, the Cowboys,
enforces. As I read the story and it
explained gamblers and drinkers and people shooting their revolvers just like a
lot of the scenes in Tombstone. One thing
that I thought this story did well was show how humanity can restart. While Roaring Camp is a dirty and rough place
everything changes as soon as a baby is brought into the mix. As soon as the baby is born, and the mother
dies, all of those men who were originally depicted as mean and gruff become
more human, more motherly. I think it is
almost comical how clean and caring the men become. Each one of them does his part to care for
the baby, Tommy Luck, the “luck” of Roaring Camp. It’s funny how when the baby is born another
character, Kentuck, calls him a “damned little cuss” but he uses it is as an
endearment. It is clear that all of the
men in the town love the baby and it helps them to better themselves. I think that this story does a great job of
showing that anyone can change if they find something worth caring for. For these men, before the baby, there was
nothing to care for. They were simply
trying to get by, avoid the law, make a little money, and have a good
time. They gambled, they fought, they
drank to their fill whenever they pleased.
They were noisy, they were messy and they were just downright
gross. Once they find something worth
truly caring for, the baby which is attributed to their newfound luck, they
really turn over a new leaf. They begin
to refurbish the broken furniture within the camp. They start to bathe regularly if they intend
to spend time with the baby, they are quiet and they are more civilized. The end of the story is tragic which I think
only attests to the fact that in an instant everything can change in an
instant. As soon as the flood comes it
changes the landscape and the well-being of the camp. Many people die, including the baby and
Kentuck and the men who survive are left to rebuild for themselves and
restart. Their lives change again in an
instant just as quick as they did when little Tommy Luck was born and the camp
decided that keeping him would be the right thing to do.
Here's a question inspired by your post: the men see Tommy Luck as good luck, and yet although they become cleaner and better, they all die. Could he be considered bad luck?
ReplyDelete